Fantasy has an intimidation problem. Walk up to the shelf as a newcomer and you’re met with ten-book sagas, invented languages, maps with unpronounceable kingdoms, and devoted fans who’ll tell you that you simply must read all fourteen volumes of something before you can have an opinion. It’s enough to make a curious reader put the book down and back away slowly.
So let’s start somewhere kinder. You don’t have to begin with the biggest, oldest, most sacred epic. You don’t have to begin with a doorstopper at all. The best entry into fantasy is the one shaped like something you already love — a hobby, a kind of world, a show you can’t stop thinking about. Fantasy is vast enough that whatever you’re into, there’s a door cut to your exact size. Here are three of them.
Door one: start with what you do
The things you already spend your time on are secret fantasy gateways. The genre has quietly built whole subgenres around real-world passions, and starting there means the magic feels like an upgrade to something familiar rather than a leap into the unknown.
If you’re a gamer, LitRPG and progression fantasy will feel like coming home — leveling up, skill trees, dungeons, and stat screens, but as story. It’s the most natural on-ramp in the genre for anyone who’s ever ground out a side quest. Start with He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon and Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman, then explore the LitRPG shelf.
If you love history — the politics, the battles, the slow grind of empires — then grounded, low-magic and historical fantasy is your lane. The magic is subtle; the intrigue and warfare feel real. A strong starting point: The City of Brass by Shannon A. Chakraborty. Browse more under historical fantasy.
If you’re drawn to romance, romantasy is fantasy’s fastest-growing door and the friendliest for a lot of new readers — the worldbuilding of fantasy with a love story at the core. Try Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros and A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, and if the romance side wins, our sister site Swoon Shelves rates the heat on every one.
Door two: start with the world you want to live in
Sometimes you don’t want a plot so much as a place — a world you can disappear into. Fantasy is the genre of worlds, and you can choose the one that matches the daydream you keep returning to.
If you want cozy and low-stakes, the rising tide of cozy fantasy trades world-ending wars for tea shops, found family, and gentle magic. No one has to save the world; someone just has to open a bakery. Begin with Legends & Lattes by Travis Baldree and The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna, or browse the cozy fantasy shelf.
If you want sweeping and epic — the grand maps, the chosen ones, the clash of kingdoms — epic fantasy is the heart of the genre. Just start with an accessible one rather than the fourteen-volume monument. A great first epic: The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien and The Final Empire by Brandon Sanderson. The full shelf lives at epic fantasy.
If you want dark and morally grey, grimdark hands you a world where no one is purely good, the stakes are brutal, and the antiheroes are unforgettable. Start with The Blade Itself by Joe Abercrombie and Prince of Thorns by Mark Lawrence, then go deeper on the dark fantasy shelf.
Door three: start with what you already watch
Your favorite shows and games are taste signals. If a screen story has ever made you wish you could stay in its world longer, fantasy is where that wish gets granted — in far more detail than any season could hold.
If you loved Game of Thrones (the political knives, the many-POV sprawl, the moral grey), point yourself at epic and grimdark. Start with A Game of Thrones by George R. R. Martin and The Fifth Season by N. K. Jemisin. More under epic fantasy and dark fantasy.
If The Witcher or your favorite RPG is your comfort watch, you want adventure-forward fantasy — monster hunts, quests, a capable protagonist and a world that rewards exploration. Try Theft of Swords by Michael J. Sullivan and The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch, or the sword & sorcery shelf.
If you grew up on Harry Potter and never left, the magic-school and portal-fantasy shelves are calling — ordinary people, extraordinary worlds, the thrill of learning magic for the first time. Begin with The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss and A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik. Explore more under portal fantasy.
One more thing before you start: read at your own pace
The last myth worth busting: you do not have to finish a series, read in publication order, or clear some imaginary canon before you’re allowed to call yourself a fantasy reader. Pick one book. If you love it, the shelf next to it is full of more. If you don’t, try a different door — there are dozens, and none of them is the wrong one.
And if you’re picking for someone else — a teen reader, a younger sibling, a classroom — every book on Grimoire Guide carries a content rating, so you can stick to gentler reads on the PG shelf or know exactly what you’re handing over before you do.
That’s the whole secret. Not a syllabus, not a reading order, not a fourteen-book commitment. Just one door you already recognize — a hobby, a world, a show you love — and a book waiting on the other side of it.
Want a few hand-picked fantasy recommendations every week? Subscribe to Grimoire Guide Weekly and we’ll send new releases and hidden gems straight to your inbox.