← Home

Theme: Supernatural Mystery

49 fantasy books in our catalogue wrestle with the theme of supernatural mystery. Sort by newest or highest-rated below. Every title is rated for content, with age recommendations and trigger warnings.

49 books
Newest firstMost popular
The Bride
The Bride
D. E. Athkins
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
Evil in the Attic
Evil in the Attic
Linda Piazza
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
The Midnight Game
The Midnight Game
Johnny Ray Barnes, Jr.
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
Pale Phoenix
Pale Phoenix
Kathryn Reiss
PGYA 12-17
The Drum, the Doll, and the Zombie
The Drum, the Doll, and the Zombie
John Bellairs;Brad Strickland
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
Goosebumps - Ghost Beach
Goosebumps - Ghost Beach
Robert Lawrence Stine
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
A Night in the Lonesome October
A Night in the Lonesome October
Roger Zelazny
PG-13Adult 18+
The Vengeance of the Witch-Finder
The Vengeance of the Witch-Finder
John Bellairs;Brad Strickland
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
The Headless Ghost
The Headless Ghost
Lynn Beach
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
The Witch Returns
The Witch Returns
Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
A Ghost in the House
A Ghost in the House
Betty Ren Wright
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
Hear the Children Calling
Hear the Children Calling
Clare McNally
PG-13Adult 18+
Whispers from the Dead
Whispers from the Dead
Joan Lowery Nixon
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
A Binding Spell
A Binding Spell
Betty Levin
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
Witchery Hill
Witchery Hill
Welwyn Wilton Katz
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
A Watcher in the Woods
A Watcher in the Woods
Florence Engel Randall
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
The House on Parchment Street
The House on Parchment Street
Patricia A. McKillip
PGMiddle Grade 8-12
A Sicilian Romance
A Sicilian Romance
Ann Radcliffe
PGYA 12-17
Big Witch Energy
Big Witch Energy
Amanda M. Lee
PG-13Adult 18+